Can You Safely Lose 3 Pounds a Week?

Whether you’re considering weight loss or already on that path, it’s helpful to set goals or milestones that can keep you motivated for steady progress. A common marker many people choose is a certain number of pounds (lbs) lost per week. If you’re looking to ramp up weight loss quickly, one question you might have is: Can you lose 3 lbs a week?

“Losing 1 to 1.5 pounds weekly allows for steady fat loss while minimizing the loss of lean muscle,” she says.

What’s more, you’re more likely to maintain slow and steady weight loss than rapid weight loss from more extreme measures like aggressive calorie restriction. “Long-term success comes from doing the basics well over and over,” Dr. Gidwani says. “A program that’s 80 percent sustainable for months or even years is better than one that’s 100 percent perfect for two weeks.”

Exactly how many pounds you should aim to lose per week depends on your personal circumstances. “For someone with a higher starting weight or significant insulin resistance, a slightly faster rate might be appropriate, especially early,” says Gidwani. “On the other hand, for individuals closer to their goal weight, even 0.5 pounds of fat loss per week can be meaningful.”

Can You Lose 3 Pounds a Week? Why It’s Not Always Sustainable

Although losing 3 lbs or more per week might be possible, especially with aggressive calorie restriction, it may not be sustainable for everyone and can often come with a cost, Gidwani says.

“What’s more important than the number on the scale is what you’re losing,” she says. “When people lose more than 1 to 1.5 pounds per week, particularly without medical supervision or proper nutritional support, it often includes water and muscle loss, not just fat.”

When it comes to safe, sustainable weight loss, what matters more than the number on the scale is consistency in your efforts, as well as other factors like monitoring your body composition, sleep, and overall health, says Gidwani.

“That’s why I never rely on the scale alone in my practice,” says Gidwani. “We assess body composition changes, protein intake, sleep, strength training consistency, and even biomarkers like insulin and inflammatory markers to ensure that weight loss is metabolically beneficial, not just rapid.”

8 Tips for Safe, Sustainable Weight Loss

You probably already know that making lifestyle changes like diet and exercise are key parts of any weight loss plan. But what specific strategies make for a sustainable weight loss plan? Safe, sustainable weight loss is any approach that helps build and preserve muscle, supports hormone balance, avoids relying on extremes, and supports mental health, says Gidwani. Her top tips are:

1. Don’t skip resistance training. Building and maintaining muscle mass is the foundation for how quickly your body burns calories, especially during weight loss. That’s because muscle is metabolically active, which means it requires more energy (calories) to maintain itself, even when resting — so, the more muscle you have, the higher your overall calorie burn.

   [4]

2. Eat enough protein. Tracking your protein intake and ensuring you’re getting enough can help as well, since it plays a key role in feeling full, staying nourished, and building muscle, says Ali McGowan, RD, a Boston-based dietitian at Sprout Out Loud and the creator of the Sprout Out Loud podcast, a series addressing nutrition and behavior change. She suggests aiming for about 1 to 1.2 grams (g) of protein per kilogram of body weight daily. (For a 200 lb person, that’s roughly 90 to 110 g of protein per day.)
3. Prioritize fiber. Most people fall far below the recommended 25 to 35 g of fiber per day, but it’s important for many things, including weight management.

   [5]

    That’s because fiber helps support gut health, blood sugar regulation, appetite control, and reduced abdominal fat over time, Gidwani says.

   [6]

    If you want to boost your fiber intake, increase it a little at a time. Adding too much at once can cause uncomfortable digestive symptoms like gas or bloating.

   [7]

4. Use body composition, not just weight, as a measure of success. DEXA (dual-energy X-ray absorptiometry) scans and waist-to-hip ratio are better indicators of fat loss than the number on the scale, says Gidwani. DEXA scans measure fat amount and bone density in your body and can be ordered through your doctor. Waist-to-hip ratio can be calculated by dividing your waist circumference by your hip circumference, with a goal of being under 0.90 for men and 0.85 for women.

   [8]

5. Eat on a consistent schedule and limit late-night eating. Try to eat your meals around the same times each day. Irregular mealtimes and late-night eating disrupt metabolic hormones like insulin and cortisol, which can have an effect on your rate of weight loss.

   [9]

6. Focus on sleep duration and quality. Believe it or not, the amount of sleep you get each night can help or hurt weight loss. Even just a few nights of poor sleep can hamper your efforts, because poor sleep has been shown to drive cravings and increase fat storage.

   [10]

7. Monitor non-weight factors. How much you weigh isn’t the only factor to keep an eye on. Keep track of your energy levels, moods, cravings, digestion, and strength, too — not just pounds lost, says Gidwani. These give better clues about whether your plan is working than the number on the scale.
8. Address any underlying causes of your weight issues. If you don’t seem to be making progress, consider whether you may have an underlying health issue that warrants a doctor’s visit. Factors like gut health, chronic stress, hormone imbalances, nutrient deficiencies, and medication side effects can all sabotage weight loss results if left unaddressed, says Gidwani.

The Takeaway

• It’s possible to lose 3 lbs per week, but it may not be sustainable in the long term, and it could even be harmful if rapid weight loss causes you to lose more muscle than fat.
• It’s usually most sustainable to lose between 0.5 and 2 lbs per week, depending on your individual circumstances.
• Rapid weight loss could lead to challenges with your metabolism, including more food cravings and fewer calories burned.
• Sustainable weight loss requires a number of approaches that take your food, energy level, mood, and body composition into account.